Calculating Main Engine Power from Six Indicator Diagrams of a Ship

Level: Management-level Certificate of Competency for marine engineer officers
Suggested time: 45–60 minutes

This exercise asks students to calculate the indicated power of each cylinder, the total indicated power of a two-stroke main engine, and an estimate of its effective output. It also asks them to assess cylinder balance and propose appropriate engineering actions.

Part A: Student Exercise

1. Ship and Engine Scenario

A commercial cargo ship is sailing at a steady speed. Its main propulsion engine is a six-cylinder, single-acting, slow-speed, two-stroke diesel engine running in fuel-oil mode.

The engine dimensions and reference rating are based on an S60ME-C10.5-GI-type engine. The manufacturer’s project guide gives a stroke of 2,400 mm and an L1 rating of 14,940 kW at 105 rpm for the six-cylinder engine.

For this exercise, assume that the ship’s specified maximum continuous rating, or MCR, is the same as that L1 rating.

Training note: The ship, operating conditions, indicator-card measurements, mechanical efficiency and cylinder-balance limit used below are simulated for this exercise.

2. Engine and Indicator Data

Parameter Value
Number of cylinders 6
Engine cycle Two-stroke, single-acting
Cylinder bore, D 600 mm
Piston stroke, L 2,400 mm
Main engine speed, N 90 rpm
Specified MCR 14,940 kW at 105 rpm
Length of each original power diagram 80 mm
Indicator spring pressure scale 2.0 bar/mm
Assumed mechanical efficiency 90%

Each indicator card represents one complete working cycle. All six cards were taken at the same steady engine speed and load.

The diagrams available with this exercise are schematic illustrations rather than actual engine measurements. Use the following planimeter readings for the calculations.

Cylinder Net Area of Power Diagram
1 792 mm²
2 768 mm²
3 696 mm²
4 808 mm²
5 784 mm²
6 808 mm²

For this exercise, the areas represent the net signed area of the full cycle, expressed as positive values. Use the given 80 mm diagram length rather than measuring a reproduced illustration.

3. Tasks for the Student

Calculate:

  1. The mean height of each power diagram.
  2. The indicated mean effective pressure, or IMEP, for each cylinder.
  3. The piston area and swept volume of one cylinder.
  4. The number of working cycles per second for each cylinder.
  5. The indicated power of each cylinder, in kW.
  6. The total indicated power of the six-cylinder engine.
  7. The estimated mechanical losses and effective power at the engine output coupling.
  8. The estimated effective power as a percentage of the stated MCR.
  9. The average cylinder IMEP and each cylinder’s percentage deviation from that average.
  10. Which cylinder or cylinders fall outside ±5% of the average IMEP.

Finally, as the chief engineer, explain what you would check before deciding whether any engine adjustment is necessary.

Note: The ±5% value is a limit selected for this classroom exercise. It is not a universal manufacturer’s limit.


Part B: Formula Sheet

1. Mean Height of an Indicator Diagram

Mean height (mm) = Diagram area (mm²) ÷ Diagram length (mm)

When the diagram area is measured in mm² and the diagram length in mm, the resulting mean height is in mm.

2. Indicated Mean Effective Pressure

IMEP, Pi (bar) = Mean height (mm) × Indicator spring scale (bar/mm)

The indicator spring scale in this exercise is 2.0 bar/mm. The equivalent displacement scale is 0.5 mm/bar.

If a spring certificate gives the scale in mm/bar, divide the mean height by that value instead of multiplying.

3. Piston Area

Piston area, A (m²) = π × [Bore, D (m)]² ÷ 4

4. Swept Volume

Swept volume, Vs (m³) = Piston area, A (m²) × Stroke, L (m)

5. Indicated Power of One Cylinder

For this single-acting, two-stroke engine, the number of working cycles per second is the engine speed in rpm divided by 60.

Indicated power, Pi (W) = IMEP, pi (Pa) × Stroke, L (m) × Piston area, A (m²) × [Engine speed, N (rpm) ÷ 60]

When IMEP is given in bar and the answer is required in kW:

Pi (kW) = [pi (bar) × 100,000 × L (m) × A (m²) × (N ÷ 60)] ÷ 1,000

A two-stroke cylinder completes one working cycle per crankshaft revolution, so the number of cycles per second is:

Cycles per second = N ÷ 60

For a single-acting four-stroke cylinder, the corresponding factor would be:

Cycles per second = N ÷ 120

Unit conversions:

  • 1 bar = 100,000 pascals (Pa)
  • 1 kW = 1,000 watts (W)

6. Total Indicated Power

Total indicated power = Pi,1 + Pi,2 + Pi,3 + Pi,4 + Pi,5 + Pi,6

7. Effective Power

Effective power, Pe = Mechanical efficiency × Total indicated power

Indicated power is the power developed in the cylinders. Effective power is the estimated useful power available at the engine output after the assumed mechanical losses.


Part C: Worked Answers for the Instructor

1. Calculate the Piston Area

First, convert the bore from millimetres to metres:

Bore, D = 600 mm = 0.600 m

Then:

A = π × D² ÷ 4

A = π × (0.600 m)² ÷ 4

A = 0.282743 m²

2. Calculate the Swept Volume of One Cylinder

Convert the stroke:

Stroke, L = 2,400 mm = 2.400 m

Then:

Vs = A × L

Vs = 0.282743 m² × 2.400 m

Vs = 0.678584 m³ per cylinder

3. Calculate the Working Cycles per Second

For a two-stroke engine:

Cycles per second = N ÷ 60

Cycles per second = 90 ÷ 60

Cycles per second = 1.5 cycles/s per cylinder

4. Worked Example: Cylinder 1

Step 1: Mean Height

Mean height = Diagram area ÷ Diagram length

Mean height = 792 mm² ÷ 80 mm

Mean height = 9.90 mm

Step 2: Indicated Mean Effective Pressure

IMEP = Mean height × Indicator spring scale

IMEP = 9.90 mm × 2.0 bar/mm

IMEP of cylinder 1 = 19.80 bar

Convert the pressure to pascals:

19.80 bar × 100,000 = 1,980,000 Pa

Step 3: Indicated Power

P_i,1 = [1,980,000 Pa × 0.282743 m² × 2.400 m × 1.5 cycles/s] ÷ 1,000

Indicated power of cylinder 1 = 2,015.39 kW

Because all six cylinders have the same bore, stroke and speed, the same calculation factor can be applied to each cylinder:

Indicated power per cylinder, P_i (kW) = IMEP, p_i (bar) × 101.7876


5. Results for All Six Cylinders

Cylinder Diagram Area Mean Height IMEP Indicated Power
1 792 mm² 9.90 mm 19.80 bar 2,015.39 kW
2 768 mm² 9.60 mm 19.20 bar 1,954.32 kW
3 696 mm² 8.70 mm 17.40 bar 1,771.10 kW
4 808 mm² 10.10 mm 20.20 bar 2,056.11 kW
5 784 mm² 9.80 mm 19.60 bar 1,995.04 kW
6 808 mm² 10.10 mm 20.20 bar 2,056.11 kW

Using the unrounded values:

Total indicated power = 11,848.08 kW

Therefore:

Total indicated power ≈ 11.85 MW


6. Estimate Effective Power and Mechanical Losses

The exercise assumes a mechanical efficiency of 90%:

Effective power = Mechanical efficiency × Total indicated power

Effective power = 0.90 × 11,848.08 kW

Effective power = 10,663.27 kW

Therefore:

Effective power ≈ 10.66 MW

The estimated mechanical losses are:

Mechanical losses = Total indicated power − Effective power

Mechanical losses = 11,848.08 kW − 10,663.27 kW

Mechanical losses = 1,184.81 kW

The 90% efficiency is an exercise assumption. Actual mechanical efficiency depends on the engine, load and measurement boundaries.

The estimated effective power is at the engine output coupling. Power measured farther along the shaft line can differ because of shaft-line losses and any power take-off.


7. Calculate the Percentage of MCR

Percentage of MCR = [Effective power ÷ Specified MCR] × 100

Percentage of MCR = [10,663.27 kW ÷ 14,940 kW] × 100

Percentage of MCR = 71.37%

The comparison uses effective power because the stated engine rating is an output rating. Total indicated power should not be compared directly with that output rating.


8. Assess Cylinder Balance

Step 1: Calculate Average IMEP

Average IMEP = [19.80 + 19.20 + 17.40 + 20.20 + 19.60 + 20.20] ÷ 6

Average IMEP = 19.40 bar

Step 2: Calculate Each Cylinder’s Deviation

Percentage deviation = [(Cylinder IMEP − Average IMEP) ÷ Average IMEP] × 100

Cylinder IMEP Deviation from Average
1 19.80 bar +2.06%
2 19.20 bar −1.03%
3 17.40 bar −10.31%
4 20.20 bar +4.12%
5 19.60 bar +1.03%
6 20.20 bar +4.12%

Cylinder 3 is the only cylinder outside the exercise’s ±5% threshold. Its IMEP is approximately 10.31% below the six-cylinder average.

This result identifies a cylinder that deserves investigation. It does not, by itself, establish the cause or prove that the engine is unsafe.


9. Management-Level Discussion: What Should the Chief Engineer Do?

Before adjusting the engine, the chief engineer should first confirm that the result is reliable:

  • Repeat the measurement at stable engine speed, load and fuel condition.
  • Check the instrument calibration, spring scale or sensor settings, diagram quality, timing and area calculation.
  • Compare the new result with previous readings and the vessel’s normal trend.

If the low reading is confirmed, the engineer should compare cylinder 3 with the other units using information available on board, such as:

  • Maximum combustion pressure.
  • Compression pressure.
  • Exhaust gas temperature.
  • Fuel injection data.
  • Air supply and exhaust conditions.

Possible explanations include measurement error, an injection or combustion issue, or reduced compression. Further evidence is needed before selecting a cause or making an adjustment.

All measurements and adjustments should follow the installed engine’s manual and the company’s procedures. MAN’s indicator-valve safety letter warns against blowing through the relevant indicator valves for cleaning while the engine is running. Engineers should follow the instructions applicable to the fitted system.

References and Further Reading

  1. Everllence: S60ME-C10.5-GI Project Guide — engine type, stroke and L1 rating.
  2. Wärtsilä Encyclopedia: Indicated Power.
  3. MAN Service Letter SL2018-658: Indicator Valve Safety.
4.5/5 - (4 votes)

One thought on “Calculating Main Engine Power from Six Indicator Diagrams of a Ship”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *