Why Auditing States Matters as Much as Auditing Ships
International maritime safety, security, and environmental protection depend not only on ships and companies, but also—very fundamentally—on how States implement and enforce international maritime rules. Even the strongest international conventions can fail if States do not apply them consistently, transparently, and effectively.
For many years, the maritime regulatory system focused mainly on:
-
Ship compliance
-
Classification and certification
-
Port State Control inspections
However, experience showed that systemic weaknesses at the State level—such as insufficient legislation, weak administration, poor oversight of delegated organizations, or lack of enforcement—were often at the root of repeated safety and pollution problems.
To address this gap, the International Maritime Organization (IMO) established the IMO Member State Audit Scheme (IMSAS). This scheme evaluates how well IMO Member States implement and enforce mandatory IMO instruments in their roles as flag States, port States, and coastal States.
To support transparency and governance, information related to IMSAS is made available through the “IMO Member State Audit Scheme (IMSAS)” module of the Global Integrated Shipping Information System (GISIS).
This article provides a comprehensive introduction and practical guide to the IMSAS option in GISIS. It explains what IMSAS is, why it exists, how it works, what information is visible in GISIS, and why this module is critically important for maritime administrations, policymakers, educators, researchers, and industry stakeholders worldwide.
Understanding GISIS and Its Role in Maritime Governance Oversight
What Is the IMO Global Integrated Shipping Information System?
The IMO GISIS (Global Integrated Shipping Information System) is an online platform managed by the International Maritime Organization that provides transparent and reliable data on ships, companies, flag States, and maritime compliance. It brings together information on safety, security, pollution prevention, port State control, and casualty reports in one place. For seafarers, maritime professionals, researchers, and regulators, IMO GISIS is a trusted tool to check vessel records, track compliance with IMO conventions, and understand global shipping performance. Its free public access supports safer seas, better regulation, and informed decision-making across the maritime industry.
The IMSAS module focuses on how States perform, rather than how individual ships comply.
What Is the IMO Member State Audit Scheme (IMSAS)?
Definition of IMSAS
The IMO Member State Audit Scheme (IMSAS) is a mechanism through which IMO Member States are audited to assess:
-
Their implementation of mandatory IMO instruments
-
Their enforcement and oversight arrangements
-
Their administrative, legal, and institutional capacity
IMSAS audits cover State responsibilities under instruments such as:
-
SOLAS
-
MARPOL
-
STCW
-
Load Line Convention
-
COLREG
From Voluntary to Mandatory Audits
Originally, IMO audits were voluntary. Over time, the international community recognized that:
-
Voluntary participation was uneven
-
Comparability was limited
-
Global consistency required a mandatory approach
As a result, IMSAS became mandatory, forming a central pillar of modern maritime governance.
Legal Basis of IMSAS
Link with the III Code
IMSAS audits are conducted against the standards set out in the IMO Instruments Implementation Code (III Code).
In simple terms:
-
The III Code defines what States must do
-
IMSAS checks whether States are doing it
This creates a structured and objective audit framework.
Mandatory Application
IMSAS is made mandatory through amendments to:
-
SOLAS
-
MARPOL
-
Load Line Convention
-
STCW Convention
All Contracting Governments to these instruments are therefore subject to IMSAS audits.
Why IMSAS Is Important for Global Shipping
Addressing Root Causes of Non-Compliance
Many safety and pollution problems stem from:
-
Weak national legislation
-
Insufficient survey and certification systems
-
Poor oversight of Recognized Organizations
-
Inadequate Port State Control regimes
IMSAS helps identify these system-level weaknesses.
Ensuring Fairness and a Level Playing Field
By auditing all States against the same standards, IMSAS:
-
Promotes consistent application of IMO rules
-
Reduces regulatory gaps
-
Supports fair competition in global shipping
Scope of IMSAS Audits
State Roles Covered
IMSAS evaluates State performance in three roles:
-
Flag State
-
Port State
-
Coastal State
Each role involves different obligations and responsibilities.
Areas Examined During Audits
Audits typically assess:
-
National maritime legislation
-
Administrative organization
-
Personnel competence and training
-
Delegation and oversight of Recognized Organizations
-
Accident investigation arrangements
-
Monitoring, review, and corrective actions
Purpose of the IMSAS Module in GISIS
Core Objectives
The IMSAS module in GISIS aims to:
-
Provide information related to the audit scheme
-
Improve transparency of audit processes
-
Support understanding of State-level compliance
-
Assist capacity building and governance learning
It is a governance and reference tool, not an audit report publication system.
What Information Is Available in the GISIS IMSAS Module?
Types of Information Provided
Depending on IMO disclosure rules and Member State consent, the module may include:
-
General information about IMSAS
-
Audit schedules and frameworks
-
References to applicable IMO instruments
-
Explanatory material on audit methodology
Detailed audit findings, non-conformities, and corrective action plans are not publicly disclosed.
Who Participates in IMSAS?
Role of IMO Member States
All IMO Member States:
-
Are subject to IMSAS audits
-
Prepare national self-assessments
-
Participate in audit and follow-up processes
Role of the IMO Secretariat
The IMO Secretariat:
-
Coordinates the audit programme
-
Trains and appoints auditors
-
Ensures consistency and confidentiality
Role of Auditors
IMSAS auditors are:
-
Qualified experts from Member States
-
Trained and approved by the IMO
-
Required to act independently and objectively
How to Access the IMSAS Module in GISIS
Step 1: Access the GISIS Platform
Users access GISIS through the IMO website.
Step 2: Select “IMO Member State Audit Scheme (IMSAS)”
From the list of GISIS modules, users select IMSAS.
Step 3: Review Available Information
Users can:
-
Understand the audit framework
-
Learn about State obligations
-
Use the information for education and policy analysis
Relationship Between IMSAS and Other GISIS Modules
The IMSAS module is closely linked with:
-
IMO Instruments Implementation Code (III Code) – audit standards
-
Recognized Organizations – delegation oversight
-
Port State Control – enforcement outcomes
-
Marine Casualties and Incidents – safety performance indicators
-
Survey and Certification – statutory compliance mechanisms
Together, these modules provide a full governance feedback loop.
Importance of IMSAS for Safety and Environmental Protection
Strengthening Prevention
By improving State systems, IMSAS:
-
Reduces the likelihood of accidents
-
Improves pollution prevention
-
Enhances enforcement effectiveness
Supporting Continuous Improvement
IMSAS promotes:
-
Self-assessment
-
Corrective action
-
Long-term capacity building
This aligns with modern quality management principles.
Practical Use Cases of the IMSAS Module
Maritime Administrations
Administrations use IMSAS information to:
-
Prepare for audits
-
Review institutional arrangements
-
Benchmark governance structures
Policymakers and Regulators
Policymakers use the framework to:
-
Strengthen national maritime legislation
-
Improve coordination between agencies
-
Allocate resources effectively
Educators and Researchers
Academia uses IMSAS information to:
-
Study maritime governance effectiveness
-
Teach international maritime administration
-
Analyze systemic safety performance
Common Misunderstandings About IMSAS
IMSAS Is Not a Punitive System
IMSAS:
-
Does not impose fines or sanctions
-
Focuses on improvement, not punishment
-
Encourages cooperation and assistance
IMSAS Does Not Replace Port State Control
PSC inspects ships.
IMSAS audits States.
Both systems are complementary.
Best Practices for Using the GISIS IMSAS Module
-
Use it as a governance reference, not a ranking tool
-
Combine it with III Code understanding
-
Integrate IMSAS concepts into maritime administration training
-
Use it to support policy reform and institutional strengthening
Educational Value for Maritime Training and Academia
For maritime education, the IMSAS module provides:
-
Insight into international maritime governance
-
Understanding of State accountability mechanisms
-
Real-world examples of systemic compliance
It is especially useful in courses on:
-
Maritime law and policy
-
Maritime administration
-
International governance systems
-
Safety management and regulation
IMSAS in the Future of Maritime Regulation
Expanding Expectations
As shipping faces new challenges such as:
-
Decarbonisation
-
Digitalisation
-
Cybersecurity
State governance quality will become even more critical.
Role of Digital Platforms Like GISIS
GISIS supports:
-
Transparency
-
Knowledge sharing
-
Capacity building
IMSAS information will continue to underpin global trust in the maritime system.
Conclusion: Auditing States to Protect Lives, Oceans, and Trade
The IMO Member State Audit Scheme (IMSAS) option in the IMO Global Integrated Shipping Information System represents a major evolution in international maritime governance.
By systematically assessing how States implement and enforce IMO instruments, IMSAS addresses the root causes of maritime accidents, pollution, and non-compliance. The GISIS IMSAS module provides a clear and authoritative gateway to understanding this essential oversight mechanism.
For administrations, policymakers, educators, researchers, and maritime professionals, this module offers a strategic view of how global shipping is governed beyond ships and companies.
In a sector where trust, consistency, and accountability are vital, IMSAS ensures that States themselves meet the standards they have agreed to uphold—strengthening safety, protecting the environment, and supporting sustainable maritime transport worldwide.
